Milani Comparisons: Matte Naked, Matte Beauty & Enchanted Topaz


Hey lovelies,

Today’s post is a comparison post with the three nude shades I own by Milani. One was limited edition and is no longer available, and that is what truly compelled me to compare them. I wanted to see if the new “Matte Beauty” is a lot like “Enchanted Topaz.” Maybe someone that follows me was wondering the same thing? I don’t know, but this post is happening anyway.

For starters, I do have separate posts with swatches of both Matte Naked and Matte Beauty. I will link those at the end of this post. Matte Naked came out with the first batch of new Milani Moisture Matte lipsticks, and Matte Beauty is part of the newer line. Enchanted Topaz came out before both Matte Naked and Beauty, I believe with a holiday set. The packaging is different, and the color was beautiful! I do still prefer the typical all gold packaging with the gold top, personally.


Swatches from left to right: Matte Naked, Enchanted Topaz, Matte Beauty

Okay, so, the first thing I noticed is that all three of these shades are pretty different. Neither Matte Beauty or Matte Naked are very close to Enchanted Topaz. I love all three of these shades, and I think they’re wonderful nudes! However, I did find that Enchanted Topaz seems to be a way drier formula than the new line of matte lipsticks. I don’t particularly mind because the more matte the better to me, and I view the mattest of formulas as a challenge to improve my lip game. If you do not feel the same way and your first experience with a matte Milani lipstick was Enchanted Topaz and you wanted to toss baby snails onto hot pavement, have no fear, the formulas are different.

The moisture matte (newer) formula is way more comfortable on the lips than Enchanted Topaz was. If you didn’t snag Enchanted Topaz, or you’re running low on it because you loved the heck out of it, there are now two other brown-nude shades to choose from!

What do you think of these swatches? What are your thoughts on the differences and/or similarities?

Also, if you like comparison posts like these, let me know or give me suggestions! Doing comparisons kinda helps me out as well, because I have a problem with buying about 10 of the same color…except for red. I will never stop buying every red lipstick.

Anyway, I hope you all enjoyed this post or found it helpful in some way! I hope you’re all having lovely days!

Stalk and talk to me:





Snapchat: lunafayebeauty

12 thoughts on “Milani Comparisons: Matte Naked, Matte Beauty & Enchanted Topaz

  1. Great comparison! I had Matte Naked but I didn’t really like it on me for some reason. I just bought it because of the hype lol. I love the Milani lipsticks though! 🙂

  2. OMG! Poor baby snails! Hahahaha 🙂 So I wonder if you mix the two new ones if you will get a color that is closer to the Enchanted one you love!?? I don’t own any of these but I loved reading it anyways and the concept behind it so I say keep the comparison posts up!

  3. Ooo that’s a good idea! I might try that! Thank you! I need to do some more comparisons with all of these lipsticks coming out because I swear I have about 50 of the exact same shade…ugh.

  4. Ha. Yeah, I was swatching blushes this morning and found two dupes in my collection. It’s kind of disturbing when you realize you keep spending money on the same shit and don’t even realize it, lol.

  5. I have been wanting Matte Blissful for such a long time! You just confirmed that I need it! I will also take a look at Matte Beauty. 🙂

  6. Awesome! I am going to have to do some lipstick shopping very soon! Which is great by me! Lol! 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s